1 | | Another Chapter | Arielle Jacobs, Between the Lines Original Cast | A Minor | 8A | 75 |
2 | | Between the Lines | Arielle Jacobs, Jake David Smith, Between the Lines Original Cast | A Minor | 8A | 75 |
3 | | Happily Ever After Hour | Between the Lines Original Cast | G Major | 9B | 148 |
4 | | Talkin' to Oliver | Arielle Jacobs, Between the Lines Original Cast | B Major | 1B | 126 |
5 | | Mr. Darcy and Me | Vicki Lewis, Between the Lines Original Cast | C Major | 8B | 83 |
6 | | Inner Thoughts | Hillary Fisher, Jerusha Cavazos, Sean Stack, Vicki Lewis, Will Burton, Between the Lines Original Cast | A Minor | 8A | 140 |
7 | | Start Again Tomorrow | Julia Murney, Between the Lines Original Cast | G Major | 9B | 177 |
8 | | In My Perfect World | Arielle Jacobs, Jake David Smith, Between the Lines Original Cast | E Major | 12B | 122 |
9 | | Crazy Chemistry | Hillary Fisher, Between the Lines Original Cast | F♯ Minor | 11A | 150 |
10 | | Butterflies | John Rapson, Between the Lines Original Cast | G Major | 9B | 109 |
11 | | I'm Not Through | Julia Murney, Arielle Jacobs, Between the Lines Original Cast | G Major | 9B | 150 |
12 | | A Whole New Story | Arielle Jacobs, Between the Lines Original Cast | A♭ Major | 4B | 101 |
13 | | Best Day Ever | Between the Lines Original Cast | C Major | 8B | 102 |
14 | | Do It for You | Wren Rivera, Jerusha Cavazos, Vicki Lewis, Arielle Jacobs, Between the Lines Original Cast | F Major | 7B | 130 |
15 | | Something to Hold On To | Jake David Smith, Between the Lines Original Cast | D♭ Major | 3B | 63 |
16 | | Leaps and Bounds | Julia Murney, Between the Lines Original Cast | A♭ Major | 4B | 163 |
17 | | Out of Character | Will Burton, Between the Lines Original Cast | C Major | 8B | 108 |
18 | | Allie McAndrews | Wren Rivera, Arielle Jacobs, Between the Lines Original Cast | E Major | 12B | 168 |
19 | | Can't Get 'Em Out | Vicki Lewis, Arielle Jacobs, Between the Lines Original Cast | G Major | 9B | 70 |
20 | | Between the Lines (Reprise) | Arielle Jacobs, Jake David Smith, Between the Lines Original Cast | E♭ Major | 5B | 89 |
21 | | Say It In Other Words | Arielle Jacobs, Jake David Smith, Between the Lines Original Cast | F Major | 7B | 81 |
22 | | Inner Thoughts (Reprise) | Hillary Fisher, Jerusha Cavazos, Sean Stack, Will Burton, Between the Lines Original Cast | B Minor | 10A | 140 |