1 | | Overture | Thoroughly Modern Millie Orchestra, Michael Rafter | A♭ Major | 4B | 113 |
2 | | Not for the Life of Me | Sutton Foster | E♭ Major | 5B | 184 |
3 | | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Sutton Foster, Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble | C Major | 8B | 99 |
4 | | Not for the Life of Me (Reprise) | Sutton Foster, JoAnn M. Hunter, Alisa Klein, Jessica Grové, Megan Sikora, Catherine Brunell, Kate Baldwin | E Minor | 9A | 112 |
5 | | How the Other Half Lives | Angela Christian, Sutton Foster | A Major | 11B | 136 |
6 | | Not for the Life of Me (Reprise) | Ken Leung, Francis Jue | C Minor | 5A | 152 |
7 | | The Speed Test | Marc Kudisch, Sutton Foster, Anne L. Nathan, Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble | D Major | 10B | 162 |
8 | | They Don't Know | Harriet Harris | A♭ Major | 4B | 110 |
9 | | The Nutty Cracker Suite | Thoroughly Modern Millie Orchestra, Michael Rafter | F Major | 7B | 106 |
10 | | What Do I Need with Love | Gavin Creel | G Minor | 6A | 95 |
11 | | Only in New York | Sheryl Lee Ralph | D♭ Major | 3B | 86 |
12 | | Jimmy | Sutton Foster | B Major | 1B | 112 |
13 | | Back at Work | Sutton Foster, Anne L. Nathan, Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble | B♭ Minor | 3A | 85 |
14 | | Forget About the Boy | Sutton Foster, Anne L. Nathan, Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble, Original Broadway Cast of Thoroughly Modern Millie | D Minor | 7A | 200 |
15 | | Ah! Sweet Mystery of Life / I'm Falling in Love with Someone | Marc Kudisch, Angela Christian | F Major | 7B | 171 |
16 | | I Turned the Corner / I'm Falling in Love with Someone (Quartet/Reprise) | Gavin Creel, Marc Kudisch, Sutton Foster, Angela Christian | F♯ Major | 2B | 87 |
17 | | Muqin | Harriet Harris, Francis Jue, Ken Leung | D Major | 10B | 115 |
18 | | Long as I'm Here with You | Sheryl Lee Ralph, Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble | D Major | 10B | 111 |
19 | | Gimme Gimme | Sutton Foster | B Major | 1B | 176 |
20 | | Finale: Thoroughly Modern Millie | Gavin Creel, Angela Christian, Sheryl Lee Ralph, Sutton Foster, Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble | D♭ Major | 3B | 102 |
21 | | Final Bows | Thoroughly Modern Millie Ensemble | F Major | 7B | 114 |