1 | | Rider's Lullaby | Jessie Mueller | C Major | 8B | 111 |
2 | | Centaurworld | Megan Hilty, Josh Radnor, Parvesh Cheena, Megan Nicole Dong, Chris Diamantopoulos, Kimiko Glenn | A Major | 11B | 83 |
3 | | Spells For Days | Megan Hilty, Parvesh Cheena, Josh Radnor, Megan Nicole Dong, Chris Diamantopoulos | G Major | 9B | 107 |
4 | | Hello Rainbow Road | Kimiko Glenn, The Centaurworld Cast | C Major | 8B | 126 |
5 | | Fragile Things | Megan Hilty, Kimiko Glenn | D♭ Minor | 12A | 131 |
6 | | Taurnado | Kimiko Glenn, Megan Nicole Dong, The Centaurworld Cast | D♭ Major | 3B | 90 |
7 | | What If I Forget Your Face | Kimiko Glenn | C Major | 8B | 79 |
8 | | Making Friendships--BOATS! | Josh Radnor, Chris Diamantopoulos, Parvesh Cheena, Megan Nicole Dong | C Major | 8B | 110 |
9 | | Frustration Tears | Kimiko Glenn | G Major | 9B | 70 |
10 | | The Key | Renée Elise Goldsberry, Kimiko Glenn | B Minor | 10A | 112 |
11 | | What You Need | Megan Nicole Dong | E Major | 12B | 92 |
12 | | He Never Says Anything Nice | Josh Radnor | D Major | 10B | 120 |
13 | | Rider's Lullaby (Reprise) | Kimiko Glenn | D Major | 10B | 96 |
14 | | The Nowhere King | The Centaurworld Cast | E Major | 12B | 99 |
15 | | Where Does Food Come From | Josh Radnor, Kimiko Glenn, Megan Nicole Dong, Chris Diamantopoulos, Parvesh Cheena | B Major | 1B | 121 |
16 | | It's Hidin' Time | The Centaurworld Cast | A Major | 11B | 101 |
17 | | My Collection | David Johansen, Kimiko Glenn | E Major | 12B | 105 |
18 | | I Stealz So I Can Feelz | Megan Nicole Dong, Kimiko Glenn | F♯ Major | 2B | 83 |
19 | | Baby's First Spell | Parvesh Cheena, Chris Diamantopoulos, Megan Hilty, Megan Nicole Dong, Josh Radnor | D♭ Major | 3B | 93 |
20 | | The Underground | Santigold, Kimiko Glenn, Megan Nicole Dong, Megan Hilty | G Major | 9B | 73 |
21 | | The Butt of the Joke | Paul F. Tompkins, Kimiko Glenn | A Major | 11B | 124 |
22 | | And We Do This Everyday | Chris Diamantopoulos, Kimiko Glenn, Fred Armisen, Megan Hilty, The Centaurworld Cast | C Major | 8B | 115 |
23 | | I Don't Know Him | Parvesh Cheena, Fred Armisen, Megan Nicole Dong, Megan Hilty | F♯ Minor | 11A | 94 |
24 | | Who Is She? | Kimiko Glenn, Megan Nicole Dong, Megan Hilty | F♯ Minor | 11A | 88 |
25 | | The Nowhere King (Reprise 2) | The Centaurworld Cast | A Major | 11B | 134 |
26 | | It's Gonna Be a While | Dominic Bisignano, The Centaurworld Cast | A Major | 11B | 120 |
27 | | Welcome to the Bay | Rosalie Craig | A♭ Major | 4B | 98 |
28 | | Who Is She? (Reprise) | Kimiko Glenn | G Minor | 6A | 102 |
29 | | Fragile Things (Reprise) | Megan Hilty, Rosalie Craig | E Major | 12B | 125 |
30 | | My Collection (Reprise) | Megan Nicole Dong | A♭ Minor | 1A | 102 |
31 | | The Hero of My Story (Comfortable Doug) | Flula Borg, The Centaurworld Cast | D♭ Minor | 12A | 115 |
32 | | Before You Go | Megan Hilty, Kimiko Glenn, Chris Diamantopoulos | C Major | 8B | 101 |
33 | | The Key (Reprise) | Renée Elise Goldsberry | B Minor | 10A | 85 |
34 | | I've Been Searching For You | Kimiko Glenn, Jessie Mueller | E Major | 12B | 171 |
35 | | Nothing Good | Lea Salonga, Megan Hilty | D Major | 10B | 99 |
36 | | Nowhere King Battle | Megan Hilty, Renée Elise Goldsberry, Brian Stokes Mitchell, The Centaurworld Cast | A Minor | 8A | 111 |
37 | | Separate Ways | Kimiko Glenn, Jessie Mueller | G Major | 9B | 138 |