1 | | Opening | Olga Merediz, Don Mayo, Stephen Bogardus, Brian Stokes Mitchell | B♭ Major | 6B | 147 |
2 | | Man of La Mancha (I, Don Quixote) | Brian Stokes Mitchell, Ernie Sabella | D Major | 10B | 144 |
3 | | It's All the Same | Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, Man of La Mancha Ensemble (2002) | A♭ Minor | 1A | 112 |
4 | | Dulcinea | Brian Stokes Mitchell, Man of La Mancha Ensemble (2002) | C Major | 8B | 131 |
5 | | I'm Only Thinking of Him | Natascia Diaz, Olga Merediz, Mark Jacoby, Brian Stokes Mitchell | F Minor | 4A | 128 |
6 | | We're Only Thinking of Him | Stephen Bogardus, Natascia Diaz, Mark Jacoby, Olga Merediz | F Minor | 4A | 81 |
7 | | I Really Like Him | Ernie Sabella, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio | F Major | 7B | 137 |
8 | | What Does He Want of Me? | Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio | F Major | 7B | 96 |
9 | | Little Bird, Little Bird | Bradley Dean, Gregory Mitchell, Man of La Mancha Ensemble (2002) | G Major | 9B | 112 |
10 | | Barber's Song | Jamie Torcellini | C Major | 8B | 109 |
11 | | Golden Helmet of Mambrino | Brian Stokes Mitchell, Ernie Sabella, Jamie Torcellini, Mark Jacoby, Man of La Mancha Ensemble (2002) | E Major | 12B | 134 |
12 | | To Each His Dulcinea (To Every Man His Dream) | Mark Jacoby, Stephen Bogardus | F Major | 7B | 146 |
13 | | The Impossible Dream (The Quest) | Brian Stokes Mitchell | A Major | 11B | 82 |
14 | | Knight of the Woeful Countenance | Don Mayo, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, Ernie Sabella, Brian Stokes Mitchell | D♭ Minor | 12A | 134 |
15 | | Aldonza | Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, Brian Stokes Mitchell | B♭ Minor | 3A | 146 |
16 | | The Knight of the Mirrors | Stephen Bogardus, Brian Stokes Mitchell | B♭ Major | 6B | 70 |
17 | | I'm Only Thinking of Him (Reprise) | Man of La Mancha Orchestra (2002), Robert Billig | F Minor | 4A | 67 |
18 | | A Little Gossip | Ernie Sabella, Mark Jacoby | F Major | 7B | 130 |
19 | | Finale Sequence: The Death of Alonso Quijana - Dulcinea (Reprise) / The Impossible Dream (The Quest) (Reprise) / Man of La Mancha (I, Don Quixote) (Reprise) / The Psalm | Brian Stokes Mitchell, Mark Jacoby, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, Ernie Sabella | F Minor | 4A | 131 |
20 | | Finale | Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, Mark Jacoby, Bradley Dean, Frederick B. Owens, Man of La Mancha Ensemble (2002) | B♭ Major | 6B | 76 |