1 | | Horrible Theme | Instrumental | A Minor | 8A | 0 |
2 | | My Freeze Ray | Neil Patrick Harris | C Major | 8B | 144 |
3 | | Bad Horse Chorus | Jed Whedon, Joss Whedon, Zack Whedon | G Major | 9B | 79 |
4 | | Caring Hands | Felicia Day | C Major | 8B | 101 |
5 | | A Man's Gotta Do | Neil Patrick Harris, Nathan Fillion, Felicia Day | E♭ Major | 5B | 134 |
6 | | My Eyes | Neil Patrick Harris, Felicia Day | B Minor | 10A | 128 |
7 | | Bad Horse Chorus (Reprise) | Jed Whedon, Joss Whedon, Zack Whedon | D Major | 10B | 80 |
8 | | Penny's Song | Felicia Day | C Major | 8B | 120 |
9 | | Brand New Day | Neil Patrick Harris | D♭ Major | 3B | 120 |
10 | | So They Say | Ensemble | F♯ Major | 2B | 134 |
11 | | Everyone's A Hero | Nathan Fillion | G Major | 9B | 92 |
12 | | Slipping | Neil Patrick Harris | E♭ Major | 5B | 119 |
13 | | Everything You Ever | Neil Patrick Harris | F Minor | 4A | 110 |
14 | | Horrible Credits | Instrumental | E♭ Major | 5B | 123 |