1 | | Silence! | Brent Barrett, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye, Deidre Goodwin, Lucia Spina | C Major | 8B | 79 |
2 | | Thish Ish It / The Right Guide | Jenn Harris, Harry Bouvy, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Jeff Hiller, Deidre Goodwin, Lucia Spina, Howard Kaye | G Minor | 6A | 145 |
3 | | If I Could Smell Her Cunt | Brent Barrett, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye, Deidre Goodwin, Lucia Spina | D Major | 10B | 86 |
4 | | Papa Shtarling | Jenn Harris, Howard Kaye | F♯ Major | 2B | 187 |
5 | | It's Agent Shtarling | Jenn Harris, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye | B♭ Minor | 3A | 140 |
6 | | Are You About a Size 14? | Stephen Bienskie, Lucia Spina, Callan Bergmann, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye | D Major | 10B | 150 |
7 | | My Daughter Is Catherine | Lucia Spina | D Major | 10B | 76 |
8 | | Quid Pro Quo | Brent Barrett, Jenn Harris, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast | E♭ Major | 5B | 146 |
9 | | I'd Fuck Me | Stephen Bienskie, Lucia Spina, Callan Bergmann, Jeff Hiller | E Major | 12B | 75 |
10 | | It's Me | Brent Barrett, Callan Bergmann, Stephen Bienskie, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye | A♭ Major | 4B | 121 |
11 | | Catherine Dies Today | Deidre Goodwin, Jenn Harris, Stephen Bienskie, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast | B♭ Minor | 3A | 76 |
12 | | Papa Shtarling - Reprise | Howard Kaye, Jenn Harris | F♯ Major | 2B | 93 |
13 | | Put the Fucking Lotion in the Basket | Stephen Bienskie, Lucia Spina | B♭ Major | 6B | 123 |
14 | | We're Goin' In | Callan Bergmann, Harry Bouvy, Jeff Hiller, Howard Kaye | B♭ Major | 6B | 146 |
15 | | In the Dark with a Maniac / Bill's Death | Jenn Harris, Stephen Bienskie, Lucia Spina, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast | D Minor | 7A | 76 |
16 | | Silence! Reprise & Finale | Jenn Harris, Brent Barrett, Silence! - The Musical Original Cast | D♭ Major | 3B | 95 |